Performance reviews are just formalized gaslighting


Agree

  • Memories are selective and biased
  • Justifies predetermined raise decisions
  • Recency bias distorts entire year
  • Power dynamics make honesty impossible

Disagree

  • Structured feedback helps people grow
  • Documentation protects both parties legally
  • Forces managers to address issues
  • Better than no feedback at all

Your turn

Where do you stand?

Take your stance

Related Hot Takes